Most of the students tend to prefer PUMBA. Also according to some of my friends studying there, it is a really good institute for pursuing MBA. Some things that make it unique from other institutes include -

• The fee is lower at PUMBA and hence, higher ROI.
• The average package offered at PUMBA is around INR 7.5 to 8 LPA which is similar to that of SIES.
• SIES is undoubtedly good for marketing, but PUMBA steals the show because of factors such as university departments and administration.
• PUMBA is a completely student-driven college. All the events held on the campus are organized and managed by students.
• Apart from academics, students at PUMBA also get trained in managing public relations, pitching, prospecting, etc.
• IIM A alumni are faculty at PUMBA for marketing management.
• SIES does not have its own hostel whereas PUMBA provides hostel facilities. The charges are very low which is Rs.4500 per year.

You should opt for SIES only if you want to pursue PGDM because PUMBA does not offer PGDM. Otherwise, go for PUMBA.